Cutting Costs by 13% Through Diversification
Introduction
Hospital operations and financial performance depend on addressing two fundamental strategic questions: where are operational failures most likely to occur, and how can inventory allocation be optimized to mitigate those risks while maximizing capital efficiency? Traditionally, health systems address these questions through siloed teams and disparate methodologies, creating operational blind spots and inefficient capital deployment. By integrating Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) with Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP), leadership can bridge operational risk management with quantitative inventory optimization—transforming supply chain management into a measurable driver of financial resilience and service continuity.
Where the Ideas Came From
FMEA dates to 1949, when the U.S. military built a simple habit into its engineering process: list everything that could go wrong with a piece of equipment, rank it by severity and frequency. Fix the pieces of equipment with the highest severity and the highest frequency before an unforeseen event occurs. NASA and the aerospace industry picked up the same habit through the 1960s.
Healthcare caught up decades later. In 2001, James Bagian — a physician, engineer, and former NASA astronaut — founded the Veterans Health Administration's National Center for Patient Safety and adapted the military method into Healthcare FMEA (HFMEA), built for teams of doctors, nurses, and pharmacists instead of engineers.
In 1947, mathematician George Dantzig built its core method while working on logistics for the U.S. Air Force with the same challenge a hospital supply director faces today: with a limited budget and limited space, what's the smartest way to allocate what you have?
Both tools were built to solve military problems and later proved themselves in hospitals. Keep two ideas in mind as you read: a complex process fails in predictable ways you can list ahead of time, and resources are always limited. This leads us to the self-reflecting question:
“Where does each dollar of supply do the best for patients?”
What It Looks Like in Practice
FMEA tells you what's likely to fail. MILP tells you where to stock up to cover it. Three real examples show what that looks like.
HFMEA is still the VA’s go-to tool for catching risk before it reaches a patient. In 2007 alone, every one of the VA’s 153 medical centers completed a mandated review of a supply-processing procedure. More than two decades after it launched, the official guidebook was updated as recently as November 2025. Any hospital safety or pharmacy team can run the same process today — it takes a facilitator and a cross-department team, not a data science degree.
At Charles Nicolle Hospital in Tunis, pharmacists used FMEA over five months in 2020 to rank 24 ways the medication process could fail. They also built a simpler scoring version so frontline staff, not just specialists, could keep using it day to day.
In a 2023 study, researchers Mariam Bader, Raja Jayaraman and Andrei Sleptchenko at Khalifa University (UAE) used MILP to decide how a network of healthcare centers should split its medical-supply orders across several vendors instead of one. The math found that spreading orders across multiple qualified suppliers cut total purchasing costs by 13.3 percent compared to relying on a single supplier. This was a modeling study, presented at an IEEE conference in Singapore, covering multiple products, time periods, centers, and suppliers, with the risk of delivery delays built in.
Side by side, the three examples show the same two tools working at different levels — an agency-wide safety program, one hospital pharmacy, and a purchasing decision:
Example | Tool Used | What It Decides | Result |
HFMEA (VA hospitals) | FMEA, adapted for healthcare | Which risks to fix before a patient is harmed | Hundreds of reviews completed; still in use after 20+ years |
Pharmacy Risk Study (Tunisia, 2023) | FMEA | Which medication-handling risks to fix first | Top risks identified; simpler tool built for everyday use |
Supply Purchasing Model (2023 study) | MILP | How to split orders across suppliers | 13.3% lower purchasing costs |
Table 1. Tool Summary Chart
The lesson across all three: FMEA and MILP are stronger together than apart. A risk review helps even without a purchasing model behind it, and a purchasing model helps even without a formal risk review. But a hospital that uses both — one to flag what's likely to fail, the other to decide where supplies should sit to cover it — is answering the whole question, not half of it.
Conclusion
FMEA has been catching failure since 1949 and MILP has been allocating scarce resources since 1947. Both were built to solve military problems, and both now have a track record in hospitals. What's still rare is treating them as one connected habit instead of two teams that never compare notes — one worried about what might break, another worried about what to stock. Closing that gap doesn't take new hires. It takes one habit: ask both teams the same two questions at the same time — what's most likely to fail, and where should our limited supplies sit to cover it.
For COOs, CFOs, and supply chain executives, uniting operational risk assessment with linear optimization transforms inventory management from a cost center into a strategic lever for capital efficiency and risk mitigation. Evaluating current processes through this dual lens ensures that capital allocation directly supports clinical availability while protecting operating margins.
Key Takeaways*
● FMEA and MILP both started as military tools, and both are already proven in hospitals.
● Hospitals that connect “what might fail” with “where we stock supplies” see measurable results.
● Neither tool needs a technical expert running the show — it needs a leader asking the right questions.
About the Author
Roberto Hernandez is an Associate Consultant with over 10 years of experience in technology, academia, and construction. 5 of those years are in leadership roles that offer a new perspective on how to improve day-to-day operations.
About Paracletes
Paracletes is a performance-based consulting firm that helps senior leaders close the gap between operations, strategy, and technology execution.
If you would like to discuss how Paracletes can help your organization reach a level of performance it has not yet considered attainable, contact us at contact@paracletes.com or visit www.paracletes.com.
References
U.S. Department of Defense, MIL-P-1629, Procedures for Performing a Failure Mode, Effects and Criticality Analysis (Nov. 9, 1949); NASA and the aerospace industry adopted the method through the 1960s.
DeRosier J, Stalhandske E, Bagian JP, Nudell T. Using Health Care Failure Mode and Effect Analysis: The VA National Center for Patient Safety's Prospective Risk Analysis System. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement. 2002;28(5):248-267.
Dantzig developed the simplex method in 1947 while serving as a mathematician for the U.S. Air Force (Project SCOOP). See MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews, "George Bernard Dantzig."
"Healthcare FMEA in the Veterans Health Administration," Patient Safety & Quality Healthcare (PSQH), 2009; VA National Center for Patient Safety, Guidebook for Proactive Risk Assessment (updated November 2025), patientsafety.va.gov.
Abbassi A, Ben Cheikh Brahim A, Ouahchi Z. Failure Mode and Effect Analysis Applied to Improve the Medication Management Process in a Pharmacy of a Teaching Hospital and a Proposal for a Simplified Rating System. European Journal of Hospital Pharmacy. 2023;30(e1): e55-e60.
Optimizing Supplier Selection and Order Allocation for Medical Supplies: A Mixed Integer Linear Approach. 2023 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management (IEEM), pp. 153-157.

